Toby Smith grew up in northwest Indiana and graduated from Purdue University with a BS in Biology. Previously a forensic scientist performing DNA, serology, and toxicology analysis, Toby is dedicated to bringing her acute attention to detail and analytical skills to better serve her real estate clientele. An enthusiastic member of the community, Toby resides with her husband, a Fishers police officer, and their two children in Fishers.
We could not be more pleased with the level of expertise and proactive customer service we received from Toby. She certainly knows the area, took the time to understand what we, the buyers wanted and ultimately guided us through the entire process. We felt she had our best interest in mind. I would highly recommend Toby. If we ever want to buy or sell again, she will be our first call.
Toby is very knowledgeable of the local market, understood our needs and desires for the home shopping phase, and was able to find us what we wanted within several weeks.
Toby found us our dream home! We told her what we were looking for and she found a house and had us looking at it within 1 hour of being on the market. We were the very first showing and she guided us through the whole process. She was very professional and knowledgeable so it made it easy for us. We have recommended all of our friends and family looking for selling house to contact her.
Toby Smith was amazing to work with! She was very knowledgeable of the area and the process. I consider myself somewhat hard to work with as I am impatient and pretty needy when it comes to finding a house. I was always online searching morning and night and would often find homes listed before most websites had them posted. Toby was able to find us our perfect house before I even knew about it. She helped us get the house in a very competitive buying market and walked us through the difficult process of the purchase. I don’t plan to move again but if I do, I will definitely use Toby!
Toby Smith was my realtor for my very first home purchase, and I couldn’t have been more lucky to fall into her hands. She made a new and stressful experience seem easy to navigate; but what stood out even more was her personal interest in my husband and I. She has reached out to us several times since we moved in to let us know she’s thinking about us, and to compliment what we’ve done with the house. Toby is the best!
Toby Smith is a wonderful agent. She is professional, sincere, knowledgeable and dependable. Working with her was the best! She listens to her clients and works very hard to meet their needs. I would highly recommend Toby Smith!
I chose Toby Smith after a difficult experience with another realtor, mainly the seller. Toby helped us find the right home for us and was a consummate professional. She pointed out items we needed to consider and always followed thru on what she said she would do. I really was thankful for Toby’s expertise. We love our home and are so thankful we found Toby and that we bought our home thru her and the Carrie Holle Group. It was a great experience, and we would highly recommend her, and use her services again if we needed them.
Toby Smith is nothing short of amazing! She listened to what I was looking for in a house and showed me as many as I needed to see until I found exactly what I wanted. She is incredibly responsive and made sure I understood every part of the process as a first-time home buyer. If you are looking for someone both professional and personable to help you find your next home, look no further than Toby Smith!
The Holle group was amazing, and our realtor Toby Smith was absolutely amazing during such a stressful time. We couldn’t have asked for a better realtor, and we now own our first home and it is a dream home for my wife and I!
Toby worked very hard to find our perfect home and did a great job showing us many in the Fishers area. She was excellent! We would definitely recommended her and use her expertise again.
My realtor Toby Smith went out of her way to make sure we found the perfect home. I moved here from out of state and she made such a stressful move so much easier. She was available for my husband and I on very little notice when we were in town to look at homes. She was very understanding of our situation. It was such a pleasure to work with her.
Toby was great, this was my first home purchase and tony made is easy and enjoyable. She focused on the need we stated we wanted in a home and showed us a bunch if homes always smiling and friendly while doing so. It took a little time and we saw a lot of home but through out it all Toby was friendly and professional and would definitely recommend her to friends and family and will reach out to her in the future if I sell my home. Could not find a better Realtor. I’m definitely a happy and satisfied customer.
Toby Smith was amazing to work with. She made herself available to us 24 hours a day (we did try not to bother her that often though!). We did a new build while getting our house ready to sell. She was there for every step of the way leaving no questions unanswered. If she suggested we do something (paint, re-carpet, new light fixtures, etc.), we trusted her and we did it. It worked. She sold our house within 48 hours for over asking price. We closed on our existing house 1 week after we closed on our new build. The timing worked out perfectly. I can’t stress how great she was to work with. I would recommend her to anyone looking to buy/sell! It couldn’t have been a more smoothly run process and we certainly have her to thank!
Toby was awesome to work with! By far, the most seamless home purchase I have ever had. She had a high sense of urgency and walked me through the process methodically answering all of my questions along the way. I highly recommend her and will definitely use her again in the future.
Toby helped us buy a house in Carmel this year and I would definitely use her again. Her warm friendly professional manner made her pleasant to work with. She was very flexible with our changing schedule traveling from outside the area to house hunt. I felt she really cared about helping us find a house that met our needs not just making another commission. She helped us avoid some difficulties by pointing out potential problems. She gave good advice and worked out problems in the closing period. I highly recommend Toby Smith.
My husband and I worked with Toby at Highgarden. She is very sweet and worked very hard to find us exactly what we wanted. We had a few set backs(not her fault) and she was there to hear our frustrations and help us move through them to find our home. Toby is knowledgeable, professional, and was a pleasure to work with. Such a pleasure that we recommended her to our parents. They loved her as well and she helped them find a wonderful home! Thank you Toby!
Toby watched closely for a condo to become available in the complex we were interested in, so we learned about this condo being for sale the day it was listed. Toby was pleasant and efficient to work with.
My husband and I met Toby via scrolling through the Highgarden website. She contacted me right away. We are new to the market and wasn’t sure if and where we’d like to buy. After learning about the different areas. We chose Carmel’s Village of West Clay. Toby is very educated and knowledgeable about the areas, what we were looking for and the market. She met us at an older home to get an idea what we liked. Then to a new construction community. Now we are awaiting our February finish date. But Toby has totally taken over and gotten us the best deal and handled everything very professionally. We really appreciate her help and can’t wait until we close. We highly recommend Toby to all our friends, associates, neighbors and family.